Drywall or Plaster? How to Tell

Knock on the wall. The answer shapes your whole repair.

☎ Call (301) 679-9193

Get a Free Estimate

Tell us about your project. Free estimates, no pressure.

Call or text now
(301) 679-9193
Serving Silver Spring and Montgomery County, MD

Get Your Free Quote

Answer a few quick questions — takes about 30 seconds.

Question 1 of 4

What does your drywall need?

Drywall installer carrying a sheet into a framed Silver Spring basement

Drywall vs plaster in Silver Spring: the knock test

Drywall vs plaster in Silver Spring, MD starts with a knock. Plaster sounds solid and dull. Drywall sounds slightly hollow. That one test tells you half the story.

What plaster is

Plaster went up wet, over wood lath. Two or three coats, troweled by hand. It hardens into a dense shell. It blocks sound well. It can last a century.

When it fails, it fails in sheets. Crumbling off the lath. Cracks where it still moves. Fixing it takes different skills than drywall.

What drywall is

Drywall is board from a factory. It goes up fast and fixes fast. Most homes built after 1950 use it.

Repair or replace?

Sound plaster: keep it. Repair cracks. Skim-coat rough surfaces smooth. You get old walls with new looks.

Failing plaster: replace it. Crumbling off the lath does not come back. New drywall goes in straighter than the old plaster ever was.

We make the call with you on the free visit. See plaster repair.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if my walls are plaster?

Knock. Plaster sounds solid and dull. Drywall sounds a bit hollow. Pre-1950 homes are usually plaster. We confirm on the free visit.

Is plaster better than drywall?

It is denser and quieter. It is also harder to repair. Sound plaster is worth keeping. Dead plaster is not.

Can you skim-coat plaster to look like drywall?

Yes. Skim coating gives plaster a smooth, modern surface. Best fix for sound-but-rough plaster.

Does plaster cost more to repair?

Yes. The labor is slower and more skilled. But keeping good plaster beats the cost of a full tear-out.

☎ Call (301) 679-9193